142: Annual Performance Review

silhouette of road signage during golden hour

Hey, đź‘‹ Scott from The Sales Mastermind here.

Today’s edition only takes 3 minutes.

Would two more deals before Christmas make a difference for you?
I'm launching something in November just for you - check out the details here.​
Doors close TUESDAY 17TH NOVEMBER

Losing a seller costs far more than a slight drop in productivity. The best sales leaders run great annual performance reviews to keep their team engaged.


Today we’ll cover:

  • Story Time
  • What is an Annual Performance Review
  • Structured Agenda
  • Best Practices
  • Mistakes To Avoid

Storytime

A coachee of mine (let’s call her Alex) runs a team of two sellers.

In February, we weren’t sure the business could afford two salaries for two salespeople as the numbers weren’t quite working.

As of September, the two of them closed over $1.3 million in annual revenue for the business, and the numbers definitely add up.

Last month, one of the sellers asked Alex for their One Year Performance Review.

Obviously, Alex said yes.

But she didn’t know what to say or how to structure the meeting, and she was especially unsure how to handle the inevitable “pay rise” ask that comes from a performance review.

The below is the format we came up with for Alex to be prepared, avoid discussing money (bonuses and pay rises are done in December every year), and make sure the Seller is content and happy with his progress.

What is an Annual Performance Review

Annual Performance Reviews are, and should be, a highly structured meeting that every manager runs with every member of their team. Especially full-time members of the team.

The reviews you run with your sellers are different because sales success is overt and binary. Either the Seller hit target, or they didn’t. However, a good review meeting balances the quantitative ($$ to target) and the qualitative (how the Seller has improved).

Also, the annual meeting is important because it helps solidify your working relationship, gives you a chance to understand each Seller’s motivations, and gives the Seller a formal opportunity to provide feedback on your management style.

Note: This format works well for a quarterly review if you want to be even more engaged with your sellers.

Structured Agenda

This meeting should be your most structured meeting. The structure should also remain consistent.

I recommend 1.25-1.5 hours for the meeting (not a standard 60minutes). And for the majority of the agenda to be seller-led.

A sample agenda looks like:

  • Overall Summary - You frame the purpose of the meeting and the desired outcome/s.
  • Big Wins - The Seller starts by discussing their 3-5 biggest wins from the year. Ideally, these are balanced between qualitative and quantitative.
  • Numbers - You lead a quick discussion on the KPIs and Quota they are expected to maintain. For example: Revenue, Number of Deals, Close Rate, etc.
  • Challenges - You and the Seller discuss 3-5 challenges from the past 12 months and create a plan to address each in the next 3-12 months.
  • The Future - The Seller tells you where they want to be in 1-3-5 years and where they want their career to go. Then you both work out 1-2-3 actions that you can take over the next 3-12 months to support them.
  • Expanded Project (Optional) - The Seller explains a project or initiative they would like to lead or progress. “No Thanks” is acceptable.
  • Start, Stop, Continue - The Seller provides feedback on your management style and specific activities they would like you to start, stop, or continue. If time, you provide similar feedback.
  • Wrap Up (and Commitment) - The Seller summarises the meeting, and you both agree on action items and commitments. Ideally, the Seller then sends a follow-up email from a standardised template.

Best Practices

Preparation - this meeting should have prep from both sides, a structured agenda, and, ideally, a worksheet for the Seller to complete beforehand.

Talking first - after the Overall Summary, the Seller should always speak first. If you (the manager) talk first, the Seller will mirror and tone down what you said.

No surprises - a Seller should not be surprised either positively or negatively during this review. If they are, you need to work on your leadership/management skills.

Allow time - most people default to 1 hour for all meetings. The annual performance review often needs more than this. 1.25-1.5 hours is recommended.

Expanded opportunities - sellers want to grow as much as anyone else. Decide in advance if you’ll be pushing the Seller to take on more responsibilities, or trial taking on more responsibilities. This includes a promotion track, or not. Know your answers before the meeting starts.

Mistakes To Avoid

Talking too much - the Seller should be talking the majority of the time. This meeting is about them, where they are going, what they want, and how you can help them get there.

Discussing pay - save pay/comp/bonuses for a separate conversation. Tell the Seller it will be discussed separately so they aren’t waiting for that discussion.

Quantitative only - sellers are human. Whether they hit quota, or not, is binary and unambiguous. Discuss numbers but don’t make the whole meeting about numbers.

Desire for growth - some sellers are content to stay where they are. Don’t force growth on someone who is hitting quota and content.

And that’s how to run an Annual Performance Review for a seller. I’m putting together a worksheet for my clients based on the above. Do you want a copy? Reply “Worksheet”, and I’ll send it over.


Until next week,
Scott Cowley

PS Are you a founder who wants to close two unexpected deals before Christmas? Click here to learn more. Doors close Tuesday 17th.

Hi! It's The Sales Mastermind

I help founders who sell, but aren't "sales"people. Are you open to one hyper actionable sales tip per week, useful for your very next sales meeting and consumable in 4 minutes or less?